Introduction, section 1 of the free video course Constructive Feedback at Work
What is Constructive Feedback?
Constructive feedback is a response to a person’s activity with the purpose of helping them adjust to become more effective. By that definition, real feedback is constructive by nature: it is specific, it addresses the activity and not the person’s character, it is meant to help, and it points toward future performance.
By Professor Cameron Conaway, Penn State Smeal College of Business
Feedback is all around you
Broadly speaking, feedback is a response or a signal that causes you to gain insight or otherwise take a different approach to what you’re doing.
Perhaps one Christmas morning you loaded your daughter with so many small gifts under the tree that, halfway through opening them, you noticed she had become extremely bored. She lost the joy and wonder you hoped each gift would bring. That’s feedback to you, and perhaps next year you’ll course-correct based on it.
Here is another story. Notice how many places hold feedback.
You take the stage at an industry conference. For three months, you’ve been working on your presentation. Early on, your first joke to break the ice seems to fall flat. As you progress, you notice people shuffling in their seats, and a few yawns. This causes you to speed up, which means you stumble on your words and rush past the most important part. Nobody has questions during the Q&A, and nobody sticks around to talk to you afterward. You head straight back to your hotel room. In your gut, you know you underwhelmed a whole bunch of people and did not give your best performance. A week later, the conference survey proves your gut right: attendees gave you an average score of 2.7 out of 5, and you needed at least a 4.2 for a chance to be invited back next year.
All of the feedback in that story was nonverbal. We tend to think of feedback as the words somebody says to us, and of course it is. It is also all of the other signals around us throughout the day, from our sense of somebody’s boredom to the sense in our own gut.
Separate the signal from the story
One of the keys to improving with feedback is refining our ability to discern the truth of the signal from our potentially wrong narratives about it. We humans are meaning-making machines. Sometimes this works in our favor, but many times we weave pieces of information into a narrative that simply isn’t true.
In the speaker’s story, it could be that attendees were rustling and yawning because they were an international team coming off a long series of flights and still feeling the jet lag. And that 2.7 score may have come because, when you assumed they were disinterested and sped up, you blitzed through so fast and stumbled so much that they struggled to stay with you.
This course concentrates on the mostly verbal feedback we give and receive at work. Keeping these stories in mind helps us remember that feedback, and opportunities to improve how we work with it, are accessible in nearly every moment of our lives.
A definition of feedback
Putting an official definition on the table is kind of a big deal, for two reasons. First, the alternatives are the rather clunky dictionary definitions or the many feedback definitions that aren’t about human communication, and many articles and books about feedback never offer a definition at all. Second, a definition becomes a flag in the ground for you and your team. As you collectively work to improve your feedback capabilities, you may find yourselves referencing your shared definition to ensure alignment.
Here is how I define feedback.
Feedback is a response to a person’s activity with the purpose of helping them adjust to become more effective.
Feedback comes in various forms, including evaluative (how you did and where you are), appreciative (how you are valued and recognized), and coaching (how you can improve). The feedback definition guide explores the definition and dozens of related terms.
By this definition, all feedback is meant to be constructive. Some people put the word “constructive” in front of feedback as if to make 100% sure they are talking about the helpful kind. The four parts below explain why the definition already requires it.
The four parts of the definition
A response
Feedback is a response, meaning there was some stimulus, such as a behavior or a performance, that the feedback responds to. When giving feedback, keeping stimulus and response in mind gets you beyond vague statements like “Great work” to something more specific and constructive about the behavior or performance.
Specific and constructive
“On our last project, you brought an exceptional mix of team leadership and attention to detail. You kept each team feeling empowered and moving forward while also ensuring we carefully thought through the nuances of every customer touchpoint. Great work.”
As a feedback receiver, keeping stimulus and response in mind helps you ask questions when feedback is too general to make sense of.
A reply to “Great work”
“I really appreciate that. And since I’m always working to reflect on and improve my performance, might you have some specific details in mind about what you think worked particularly well on this one?”
Effective feedback is always specific feedback. If you aren’t getting it as a receiver, you can improve your chances by specifically asking for specific feedback, including specific positive feedback, which is also a key to your professional development.
To a person’s activity
Too often, we create ineffective and unhealthy feedback experiences because we forget that feedback should address a person’s activity, not a constructed story or a judgment of their character based on that activity. Imagine a colleague arriving late, again, for an important meeting.
A narrative leap
“You have a real problem managing your time. You need to get it together.”
Centered on the activity
“Hey, I noticed you were late again to our meeting. Is everything okay?”
The first version assumes you know what’s happening in this person’s life and what their problem is. Its tone isn’t about the observed activity but about your judgment of it. The second centers your observation of the activity, steers clear of character judgment, expresses concern, and gives the feedback receiver the first move to share what’s going on.
You may find that they do simply struggle to manage their time. Or you may find something altogether different: they get intense anxiety during important meetings and it causes them to run late, or their child’s chemotherapy appointment has recently been running into the time for this meeting. Either way, you will always be in a better position if you aim your feedback directly at what you observed rather than at a story you’ve come up with.
With the purpose of helping
The purpose of feedback is to be helpful. Inherent in that is what feedback is not meant to do: ridicule, belittle, embarrass, or harm. If you have the gift of giving feedback, do the inner work of understanding your intentions before you deliver it. Carve out a quiet moment and ask yourself: why am I giving this? You may uncover some surprising dimensions that reveal your intention is not to be helpful. I know this because, like you, I am part of this complex human experience. We are also part of systems that encourage us to act in certain ways, including ways that may harm others. So check your intention at the door before entering a feedback conversation.
Two more things to keep in mind. First, even with the purest intention, you can still give terrible feedback or give feedback terribly. If the feedback doesn’t land well, honor that it didn’t land well rather than defending yourself. In my experience, a far healthier and more effective alternative is to take your armor off and walk bravely into the conversation, not away from it.
Instead of this
“I didn’t mean it like that.”
Try this
“Oh, I understand how what I said could be interpreted that way. That’s not quite what I meant. Can I try again?”
Second, what counts as helpful is partly subjective. I once worked in a toxic department where colleagues treated each other more as stepping stones up the hierarchy than as teammates. My manager gave me feedback about my need to act more aggressively in that way. His intention was to be helpful, and had I adopted his feedback, it probably would have helped me climb the ladder in that horrible environment. But to me, the feedback was not helpful. I didn’t want help navigating that environment; I was plotting how to get out. Helpful feedback during that quarterly review would have been advice on pursuing stretch assignments in different departments, or specific advice on improving the numbers I was driving.
Helpful, constructive feedback fills gaps in understanding. It can highlight strengths we didn’t know were strengths, do the same with weaknesses, and then point the way to maximizing those strengths and shoring up those weaknesses. It also depends on the relationship. When managers and direct reports build strong relationships, each understands what the other may want and need, and the manager no longer has to take a wild guess at what kind of feedback is helpful.
To adjust and become more effective
The outcome of feedback is to help someone adjust to become more effective. It can be alluring to jump right to “more effective,” but perhaps the most important word is adjust. Feedback is not, and never was, purely about pointing out a past behavior. It responds to the stimulus and helps someone adjust, which means adjust their future performance, because what else can we adjust?
Some think feedback is only about pointing to the past and stopping there. This is why many people feel the need to say “feedforward” instead, or to put “constructive” in front of feedback. And then there are those who take the contrarian stance that feedback doesn’t work.
Feedback works. It’s all around us all the time, and it’s how we’ve improved in anything, ever. We engage in some behavior; if it’s dangerous or harmful, it often hurts, which is feedback about it; and we use that feedback to adjust our behavior in the future by not touching the hot stove. Human-to-human feedback doesn’t always work, but that’s not because something is wrong with the nature of feedback, or even with the word. It’s because human-to-human communication doesn’t always work. It’s very challenging, and it takes work. By taking this course, you are putting in the reps.
The three forms of feedback
There are many forms of feedback, but I’ve found three especially helpful for categorizing the most common ones. They come from Thanks for the Feedback: The Science and Art of Receiving Feedback Well, which in my opinion is the number one book about feedback to have on your shelf.
- Evaluative
- How you did and where you are. Think of the audience survey: it told the speaker how she scored out of 5, how she did, and where she stands on the scale. It might also come from a colleague telling you how you did on a task compared with how they think it could have gone.
- Appreciative
- How you are valued and recognized. Appreciation feels good and can increase morale, and it also reinforces that you are doing something well, which is an important part of understanding your strengths.
- Coaching
- How you can improve. With positive feedback, coaching might be specific, actionable steps to double down on your strengths. With negative feedback, it offers specific, action-oriented tips for improving what the giver perceives as your areas for improvement.
These three types are a helpful tool for framing feedback, but feedback can cut across all of them. Consider this feedback, one part at a time.
Evaluative
“You performed exceptionally well this quarter, beating your forecasted quota and making it into the top 1% of sales in your region.”
Appreciative
“And the way you did it, with a passion for our customers and a deep sense of humility, is something our leadership team and I greatly admire.”
Coaching
“Throughout the quarter, I’ve noticed you can be a riveting public speaker, particularly when you set your notes aside and speak from the heart. In my experience, building on this strength can open new doors and, if it’s an area you’d like to improve in, I just finished working with a coach to improve my own skills in this regard and I’d be happy to make the introduction. Our department can fund the expense from our professional development budget.”
The first part could be read as appreciative, but on the whole it is evaluative, because it provides comparison points against the forecast and the regional numbers. The second is clearly appreciation, and it even relays appreciation from the leadership team. The third would be coaching even without the word “coach”: the giver draws on what they observed and on their own experience to offer a way forward.
Five examples of evaluative feedback
- At the end of the quarter, you drove 10% fewer marketing leads than you forecasted. It’s evaluative because it compares the number of leads to a forecast.
- A direct report tells you, “You are the best leader I’ve ever worked with.” This can also be appreciative, but there is an element of comparison.
- You did not meet the qualifying standards to participate in the Boston Marathon.
- You moved to number four on a Duolingo leaderboard. Climbing a leaderboard is nonverbal feedback about how you’re doing against others.
- Your manager says you are in the top 5% of all performers.
Five examples of appreciative feedback
- Your basketball team’s center points to you in gratitude after a great pass.
- A colleague recognizes you in a Slack channel for going above and beyond.
- Your teacher praises you in class for always asking great questions.
- Upon returning from a dangerous military mission, one sergeant hugs another.
- A patron at the restaurant where you work leaves you a great tip.
Five examples of coaching feedback
- “Here’s what worked for me when I was in a similar position,” a colleague begins.
- Your ballet teacher offers advice on how to improve your grand plié.
- “The last two projects you managed went over budget. It wasn’t by much, but here are some principles I always put in place to ensure this doesn’t happen.”
- Through active listening and asking great questions, one teammate guides another to finding their own solution to a challenge. Peers can coach each other; coaching doesn’t have to come from someone more skilled or experienced.
- “It’s clear you have a good sense of your weaknesses, but I wonder if you have a similar sense of your strengths. Are you open to exploring how we can bring those to this situation?”
Coaching feedback can range from very specific feedback to conversational guidance that helps the recipient find new perspectives or make better decisions.
What feedback literacy is
Ultimately, what this course is trying to do is improve your overall feedback literacy.
Feedback literacy is an individual’s understanding of and capacity to effectively give, receive, process, ask for, and use feedback.
The term has research roots in the world of education, where it is primarily used to describe students’ ability to receive feedback. I’ve expanded its use, pulling it into the business world so we have a broad term for overall feedback capacities.
The Feedback Deck has a suit for each of the five feedback skills. Every card distills one skill into something you can hold, share, and act on immediately.
Take it further
Everything below is built on the five-component feedback literacy framework: seeking, receiving, processing, using, and giving. I made the deck so you could hold the work in your hands, the certifications so you could prove it, and the training so your whole organization can practice it.
The Feedback Deck
$2950 evidence-based cards across the five suits of feedback literacy. Every card distills one skill into something you can hold, share, and act on immediately, with a QR code linking to a companion video I recorded for that card.
Feedback Literacy Certification
$199 per tierThe Feedback Literacy Certification establishes your competency across all five skills. Completing it unlocks FLC-A, which extends the framework into organizational and leadership application. Both are self-paced and come with a LinkedIn credential.
Teams and enterprise
From $42 per employeeBring the deck and certifications to your whole organization, with a five-tier corporate rate card and enterprise deployment support.
Continue the course
All lessons in Constructive Feedback at Work
- Course Overview
- What is Constructive Feedback?
- Why is Feedback Important?
- Why is Feedback Challenging?
- How to Receive Feedback
- How to Process Feedback
- How to Use Feedback
- How to Give Feedback
- How to Ask for Feedback
- Building a Feedback Culture
Related: the 33 types of feedback, 18 examples of feedback, and frequently asked questions about feedback.
Read the full video transcript
Hi there and welcome to the Introduction.
Let’s dive right into our first section:
Broadly speaking, feedback is a response or a signal that causes you to gain insight or otherwise take a different approach to what you’re doing. For example, perhaps during one Christmas morning you loaded your daughter with so many small gifts under the tree that halfway through opening all of them you noticed she became extremely bored. She lost the joy and wonder you hoped each gift would bring to her. That’s feedback to you. And perhaps next year, you’ll course-correct based on this feedback.
Here’s another story, see if you can spot all the places where there’s feedback. You take the stage at an industry conference. For three months, you’ve been working on your presentation. Early into it, your first joke to break the ice seems to fall flat. As you progress, you notice folks shuffling around in their seats, a few yawns. This causes you to speed up your presentation, a move that means you stumble on your words and rush past the most important part. Nobody had questions during the Q & A and nobody stuck around to talk to you afterward. After it’s over, you head straight back to your hotel room. In your gut, you know you underwhelmed a whole bunch of people and did not give your best performance. A week later, results from the conference survey proves your gut to be right: those who attended your presentation gave you an average score of 2.7 out of 5, and you needed at least a 4.2 for a chance to be invited back next year as a guest speaker.
Did you notice all the feedback throughout that story? And did you notice that it was all non-verbal? While we tend to think of feedback as the words somebody says to us, and of course it is, it’s also all of these other types of signals that are all around us throughout the day – from our sense of somebody’s boredom to the sense in our own gut. Now, one of the keys to improving in this realm of feedback is refining our ability to discern the truth of the signal from our potentially wrong narratives about it. Us humans, we are meaning-making machines. Sometimes this works in our favor, but many times we weave various pieces of information to create a narrative that simply isn’t true. For example, in our story about the speaker, it truly could have been that attendees were rustling and even yawning because they were an international team coming off a long series of flights and still feeling the jet lag of it. And that 2.7 score may have been because, when you assumed they were disinterested and adjusted by speeding up your presentation, you blitzed through so fast and stumbled so much that they struggled to stay with you.
As we dive into constructive feedback, focusing on the mostly verbal kind we give and receive at work, keeping these stories in mind can help us remember that feedback and opportunities to improve how we work with it are accessible to us in nearly every moment of our lives.
Okay, so let’s put an official definition of feedback on the table. This is actually kind of a big deal for a few reasons. First, because otherwise we have either the rather clunky dictionary definitions you may find or the many feedback definitions that aren’t about human communications. And, unfortunately, many of the articles and books about feedback fail to put forth a definition. And another reason it’s important to have a definition is because it becomes a flag in the ground for you and your team. As you all collectively work to improve your feedback capabilities, you may find yourself referencing your shared definition to ensure alignment.
So here goes. This is how I define feedback.
Feedback is a response to a person’s activity with the purpose of helping them adjust to become more effective. Feedback comes in various forms, including evaluative (how you did and where you are), appreciative (how you are valued and recognized), and coaching (how you can improve).
Let’s unpack this a bit. First, we have here that feedback is a response, meaning there was some stimuli — like a behavior or performance — that the feedback was in response to. When giving feedback, it’s important to keep this concept of stimuli and response in mind because doing so will allow you to get beyond making vague feedback statements like “Great work” to something more specific and constructive about the behavior or performance, such as: “On our last project, you showed an exceptional mix of team leadership and attention to detail. You kept each team feeling empowered and moving forward while also ensuring we carefully thought through the nuances of every customer touchpoint. Great work.” Likewise, as a feedback receiver, keeping stimulus and response in mind can help you ask questions if and when you do receive feedback that is too general for you to make sense of. In responding to that “Great work” comment, for example, you might ask something like: “I really appreciate that. And since I’m always looking to reflect on and improve my performance, might you have some specific details in mind about what you think worked particularly well on this one?”
We will cover this in more detail in future modules, but keep in mind that effective feedback is always specific feedback. And if you aren’t getting it as a receiver, you can improve your chances by specifically asking for specific feedback – including asking for specific positive feedback, as this too is a key to your professional development.
Next up: note that this is a response “to a person’s activity.” Remember when I mentioned us humans being meaning-making machines? Well, that function can cause some issues here. Too often, we end up creating ineffective and unhealthy feedback experiences because we forget that feedback should focus on a person’s activity, not on a constructed story or our judging a person’s character based on that activity. You might imagine a colleague showing up late, again, for an important meeting. Saying something like “You have a real problem managing your time. You need to get it together,” is a narrative leap… it’s assuming you know what’s happening in this person’s life and you know what their problem is. The tone here isn’t so much about the observed activity but about your judgment of it. Instead, you could say: “Hey, I noticed you were late again to our meeting. Is everything okay?” This approach centers your observation of the activity, steers clear of character judgment, shows concern, and gives the feedback receiver the first move to share what’s going on. You may find that, indeed, they do simply struggle to manage their time. Or, you may find something altogether different, like how they get intense anxiety during important meetings and this causes them to run late… or perhaps how their child’s chemotherapy appointment has recently been running into the time for this meeting. Either way, you will always be in a better position if you focus your feedback directly on what you observed rather than on a story you’ve come up with.
Next up: we have that the purpose of feedback is to be helpful. It should go without saying, but inherent in this is what feedback is not meant to be: it is not meant to ridicule or belittle. It is not meant to embarrass. It is not meant to harm. Those who have the gift of giving feedback will put themselves in a much better position if they do the inner work of understanding their intentions prior to delivering the feedback. By carving out a quiet moment before giving feedback to ask yourself — why am I giving this? — you may uncover some surprising dimensions that show you your intention is not meant to be helpful. I know this because, like you, I am also part of this complex human experience. And we are also part of systems that encourage us to act in certain ways, including ways that may harm others. And, for various reasons, we all come at things with different motivations. So I encourage you to check your intention at the door prior to entering into a feedback conversation.
Now, there are two more aspects to keep in mind here.
The first is that, even if you approach feedback with the purest and greatest intention, you can still either give terrible feedback or give feedback terribly. And, if the feedback doesn’t land well — perhaps for one of those reasons — you should honor that it didn’t land well rather than trying to defend yourself by saying, “I didn’t mean it like that.” In my experience, a far healthier and effective alternative is not to put on the armor of defending yourself but to take your armor off and walk bravely into (not away from) the conversation. Rather than, “I didn’t mean it like that” you might say, “Oh, I can see how what I said could be interpreted that way. That’s not quite what I meant. Can I try again?”
The second aspect here is that there is a subjective element to what is considered helpful. For example, I once worked in a toxic department where colleagues saw each other more as stepping stones up the hierarchy rather than as teammates. My manager gave me feedback about my need to more aggressively act in that way. To him, his intention was to be helpful. And, indeed, had I adopted his feedback, it probably would have helped me climb the ladder in this horrible environment. But, to me, the feedback was not helpful. I didn’t want help navigating this environment; in fact, I was actually plotting how to get out… so helpful feedback during that quarterly performance review would have been, perhaps, advice on how to pursue stretch assignments in different departments or specific advice on how I could improve the numbers I was driving.
As you are likely seeing at this point, feedback can be challenging because human communication can be challenging. And we often exacerbate these feedback challenges when we split feedback into camps — as though one side is purely the givers and one side is purely the receivers, with little overlap between. This can result in, for example, not managers and direct reports building strong relationships so they understand what each may want and need and, from that place, forming an effective feedback relationship, but, rather, the manager taking a wild guess on what kind of feedback is helpful. Helpful, constructive feedback fills gaps in understanding. It can highlight strengths we didn’t know were strengths, and do the same with weaknesses… and then point the way to how we can maximize those strengths and shore up those weaknesses. In my current role, my manager and I have empowering and honest 1-1 conversations several times each month. And I try to have the same for those who report to me. As such, my manager has a great sense for what kind of feedback is most helpful.
Now that we’ve covered intention, let’s get to the outcome. The outcome of feedback is ultimately to help someone adjust to become more effective. While it can be alluring to jump right to “more effective,” perhaps the most important point here is adjust. Feedback is and never was about purely pointing out a past behavior. As you see in our feedback definition, feedback isn’t just about responding to the stimulus, it’s about responding to the stimulus and helping someone adjust… which means adjust their future performance… because what else can we adjust? Some think feedback is only about pointing to the past and, basically, stopping there. This is why many folks feel the need to say “feedforward” rather than feedback, or even put the word “constructive” in front of feedback as if to make 100% sure we’re talking about helpful feedback. And then there are those who take a contrarian stance of saying feedback doesn’t work.
Team — feedback works. It’s literally all around us all the time. It’s how we’ve improved in anything ever. Feedback is actually why we’ve been able to make it through this world and remain alive; we engage in some behavior, if it’s dangerous or harmful, it often hurts… which is feedback about it… and we use that feedback to adjust our behavior in the future… by not touching the hot stove, or whatever. This is how feedback works. Now, yes, human-to-human feedback communications doesn’t always work… but that’s not because there’s something wrong with the nature of feedback or even the word feedback… it’s because, frankly, human-to-human communication doesn’t always work… as you may have noticed in your life, it’s very difficult. It takes work… and by engaging in this course you are putting in the reps right now… and, as I think you’ll see once you bring what you’ve learned in this course into your work, these reps will help both yourself and those around you. Lastly, to put a bow on this section, yes, it’s not about adjusting for adjusting sake… it’s about adjusting to become more effective… which, again, means more effective in some future performance or behavior.
And, lastly, let’s spend some time on the three common feedback forms here. There are many forms of feedback, but I’ve found these three types to be especially helpful in allowing us to easily categorize the most common types. These come from a fantastic book titled Thanks for the Feedback: The Science and Art of Receiving Feedback Well. In my opinion, this is the #1 book about feedback you should have on your shelf if you care about this topic. I’ll link to it in the description. Okay, so you can think of evaluative as like the audience survey we mentioned earlier. This survey let the speaker know how she scored out of a possible 5 points. In this sense, it let her know how she did and where she stands on the scale. Evaluative feedback might also come from a colleague, who provides feedback (positive or negative) about how you did on a particular task compared to how they think it could have gone. Appreciative, as you can guess, is the kind of feedback that makes you feel seen and valued. The coaching feedback type specifically calls out how you might be able to improve. With positive feedback, coaching feedback might be specific and actionable steps you can take to double-down on your strengths. With negative feedback, the coaching feedback type would provide specific and action-oriented tips for how to improve upon what the feedback giver perceives as your areas for improvement. Keep in mind here that, while these three types can be a helpful tool for framing the many types of feedback, feedback can cut across all of them. For example, consider this feedback and see if you can find the three types within it:
“You performed exceptionally well this quarter, beating your forecasted quota and making it into the top 1% of sales in your region.”
While that first part could be seen as Appreciative, on the whole I’d say it falls into Evaluative – especially because it provides the comparison points against the forecast and against the regional sales numbers.
“And the way you did, with a passion for our customers and a deep sense of humility, is something myself and our leadership team greatly admires.”
This one is clearly appreciation. In fact, the giver is even going beyond their own appreciation to relay appreciation from the leadership team.
“Throughout the quarter, I’ve noticed you can be a riveting public speaker, particularly when you set your notes aside and speak from the heart. In my experience, building on this strength can open new doors and, if it’s an area you’d like to improve in, I just finished working with a coach to improve my own skills in this regard and I’d be happy to make the introduction. Our department can fund the expense from our professional development budget.”
Even if we took the word coach out of this one, this would be an example of coaching feedback. The feedback giver here highlights an area for improvement and pulls both from what they observed (the strength of speaking from the heart) and their own experience in going through some training to offer a way forward on how to improve.
To solidify our understanding of each feedback type, here are 5 examples for each:
Evaluative Feedback Example Number One: At the end of the quarter, you drove 10% fewer marketing leads than you forecasted. Notice here it’s evaluative because it’s comparing the number of leads to a forecasted number. Number Two, A direct report tells you: “You are the best leader I’ve ever worked with.” Again, while this can also be appreciative, we could consider this evaluative because there’s an element of comparison. Number three, You did not meet the qualifying standards to participate in the Boston Marathon. Number four, You moved to #4 on a Duolingo leaderboard. Notice here the mix of verbal and nonverbal types… climbing the rankings on a leaderboard is feedback about how you’re doing against others. And number five, Your manager says you are in the top 5% percent of all performers. Moving on to Appreciative Feedback, Example one: Your basketball team’s center points to you in gratitude after that great pass. Number two: a colleague recognizes you in a Slack channel for going above and beyond. Number three: your teacher praises you in class for always asking great questions. Number four: Upon returning from a dangerous military mission, one sergeant hugs another. And number five: a patron at the restaurant where you work leaves you a great tip. Notice the importance here of appreciation – it not only feels good and can increase morale, but it also reinforces that you are doing something well… which is an important part of positive feedback, of understanding our strengths and improvements. Moving to Coaching feedback example number one: “Here’s what worked for me when I was in a similar position,” a colleague begins. Number two: Your ballet teacher offers advice on how to improve your grand plié. Number three: “The last two projects you managed went over budget. It wasn’t by much, but here are some principles I always put in place to ensure this doesn’t happen.” Number four: Through active listening and asking great questions, one teammate guides another to finding their own solution to a challenge. Notice here that peers can serve as coaches for each other. The coaching feedback type doesn’t always necessarily need to come from someone more skilled or experienced. And number five, “It’s clear you have a good sense of your weaknesses, but I wonder if you have a similar sense of your strengths. Are you open to exploring how we can bring those to this situation?” Notice also how the coaching feedback type can vary – ranging from very specific feedback to conversational guidance that in some way helps the feedback recipient see new perspectives or make better decisions.
To wrap up our feedback definition section, I’d like to define one more term for you, it’s one we’ll mention several times throughout the course and explore in greater detail in a future module: Feedback Literacy.
Ultimately, what we’re trying to do in this course is improve our overall feedback literacy.
Feedback literacy is a term I use to refer to an individual’s understanding of and capacity to effectively give, receive, process, ask for, and use feedback. The term has research roots in the world of education, where it is primarily used to describe students’ ability to receive feedback. I’ve expanded its use, pulling it into the business world so we have a broad term to describe overall feedback capacities. Okay, let’s move onto the next step.