Module 5 of the free video course Constructive Feedback at Work
How to Ask for Feedback
To ask for feedback well, come with a pure intention and be specific about what you want to learn. Ask your manager without waiting for a review, then widen the circle to your team, your peers, the people who inspire you, and even your interviewers. Asking is an act of ownership: you go get the feedback you need.
By Professor Cameron Conaway, Penn State Smeal College of Business
Why asking for feedback matters
Asking for feedback is perhaps the most effective way to get the feedback you need. It is also an act of ownership: you intentionally break what is, in many places, a business-world norm of passively waiting for feedback, and you go after what you need.
Kobe Bryant had Phil Jackson as a coach, one of the greatest basketball coaches in history. Kobe could have been a passive recipient of Coach Jackson’s feedback, and I’m sure many who played for him were. But Kobe went to the next level. He also sought feedback from what he called GOAT Mountain, a group of six of the greatest living players. He didn’t limit himself to the people around him. He sought feedback from whoever in the world could give him what he needed to be the best he could be.
It isn’t only for superstars. I once had a colleague who delivered spectacular web design mockups on the first try. Still, even after years of working together, he would ask for my feedback on his early versions, both to ensure he was growing and to ensure he was on the right track before spending a lot of time polishing the design.
What the research calls it
The academic literature calls this feedback-seeking behavior, abbreviated FSB. It refers to how individuals seek feedback, either by reading the actions of others to infer what they mean, which is feedback purely through observation, or by explicitly asking others for it.
The concept came to prominence through a classic 1983 paper by Susan Ashford and L.L. Cummings. To my understanding, it was the first to go deep on what it means for feedback recipients in the workplace to play a major and proactive role, to truly be owners of their professional development. The paper proposes feedback seeking as an important part of the feedback process, and a few of its points are especially compelling.
- Psychologists have accepted since at least the early 1950s that feedback improves performance.
- Individuals and organizations may both benefit when people are not only given more feedback, but helped to use asking as a strategy for getting it.
- People who ask get a more accurate appraisal of their work, and they get it at the moment it is most useful.
- Even where no one is giving verbal feedback, people process cues from their environment and derive feedback from them. In other words, even in environments where nobody is providing feedback, feedback still remains.
- People have several goals in their organizational lives beyond present performance. So ask for feedback on a range of topics, from the task you are working on now to how you may need to develop to move from, say, director to vice president.
The research has continued into the modern era. A 2022 paper, Learning Leadership and Feedback Seeking Behavior: Leadership That Spurs Feedback Seeking, describes lifelong learning as crucial for professionals and for organizations, and feedback seeking as a powerful vehicle for gaining new knowledge about one’s development and performance.
What asking does for you
- It enhances your performance. You may not always receive the feedback you need when you ask for it, but asking consistently helps you make timely adjustments and improvements to your work. And when you routinely ask, you build the habit, which means you’ll get better at it over time.
- It strengthens relationships. Asking for feedback helps build trust with colleagues and managers. It tells them you value their opinions and are committed to growing and improving.
- It increases self-awareness. When you understand your strengths and weaknesses, which asking gives you a better sense of, you can work on what you need to improve while doubling down on your strengths.
Ask about your strengths, too
Ashford and Cummings write that asking for feedback could come to represent a confident desire to understand one’s strengths and weaknesses. Note that they specifically call out strengths. Knowing your strengths is often just as important as understanding your weaknesses, and sometimes more.
A great ballet dancer could not have become great by spending most of their time trying to shore up a weakness in geometry. Or, to get more specific, they wouldn’t have carved out their unique and differentiated strengths, perhaps an incredible ability to maintain posture and balance during dynamic pirouettes, if they had spent most of their time trying to leap farther. If you’re interested in learning more about the importance of strengths, read Strengths Based Leadership by Tom Rath and Barry Conchie.
What gets in the way of asking
If asking is this valuable, why don’t more of us do it? Three barriers come up again and again.
- Cultural norms.
In many workplaces, the norm is to passively wait for feedback rather than actively ask for it. To overcome this barrier, shift your receiver mindset and recognize that asking for feedback is a proactive act of growth.
- Fear of criticism.
Many people fear receiving negative feedback. To mitigate this fear, approach feedback with an open mind and treat it as an opportunity for growth rather than criticism. It’s important to hold the complexity here: asking with an open mind does not mean the feedback you receive is good or that you should adopt it.
- A lack of psychological safety.
As Professor Amy Edmondson describes it, psychological safety is a “felt permission for candor.” When team members feel safe enough to share their thoughts, and even feel valued for doing so, they are more likely to seek and provide honest feedback. The research agrees that culture matters: Ashford and Cummings suggest the way to promote asking is to reduce the risk and effort it costs.
Six ways to ask for feedback
With the research in hand, here is how to go about asking.
- Come with a pure intention.
You may have experienced someone who seeks your feedback not to learn but to quickly get your approval so they can move forward with a project. That’s not really asking for feedback. Others seek feedback to appease someone or to perform humility, where being perceived as a humble feedback seeker matters more than gaining new knowledge. That is performative feedback. To the extent possible, seek feedback genuinely and not with hidden motives.
- Ask your manager.
This seems simple enough, but it doesn’t happen as often as it should. You don’t need to wait until a quarterly performance review. You might even start next week.
What to say to your manager
“Hey, I’ve been taking a course on feedback, and since we’ve been working together for [time period], I’d like to get your feedback on how I’m doing, maybe what you consider my strengths and areas for growth.”
- Ask your team, especially if you manage people.
Ask regularly, whether through a survey, by going individual by individual, or by pulling everybody together after a project to ask how they think it went, what worked, and where you might have done a better job as their leader. When this works, and it often does, you will both receive great feedback and model feedback-seeking behavior for your team.
What to ask after a project
“How do you think the project went? What worked well, and where could we improve next time?”
- Seek feedback indirectly.
Study those in your field or beyond who inspire you. Maybe they stand out on LinkedIn, wowed an audience at an industry conference, or write a blog you’ve read for years. Rather than merely being inspired, treat them as a case study worth really digging into. What qualities do they bring to the table that you admire? What are their strengths? Is there anything about their strengths that you can learn from to improve your own strengths or weaknesses?
- Build peer-to-peer relationships.
The research on peer-to-peer feedback is vast, and it suggests we can learn as much or more from meeting with a few peers as we can from meeting with our manager. If you’re a digital marketer in a large organization, you might reach out to another digital marketer at your level who works on a completely different part of the business, and set up a monthly one-to-one to share what each of you is learning. You might also join an organization in your skill domain. It will connect you with peers who have a similar skill set but have learned to apply it across different sectors.
- Ask after you interview somewhere.
Some people on interview panels aren’t allowed to share feedback, but many are willing if you really push for it. This feedback can be especially helpful because the interviewer likely knows the type of talent they need and has perhaps already interviewed many other candidates. It can tell you how you stack up in your field.
I’ve personally given feedback to a few people I had great interviews with but who, for various reasons, didn’t fit what I needed. On several occasions, they wrote back to say the feedback meant the world to them and would help with both their development and their future interviews.
What to say after an interview
“I appreciate the opportunity to interview for this position. Could you provide me with feedback on how to improve for future opportunities?”
Four tips for asking well
- Be specific.
Say exactly what you want feedback on.
Instead of this
“How am I doing?”
Try this
“Can you provide feedback on my presentation skills during our last meeting?”
- Be open and receptive.
Approach feedback with an open mind and be willing to listen to both positive and negative feedback. Most advice concentrates on remaining open to negative feedback, which can make many of us close down. But positive feedback is equally, and perhaps even more, important to listen to and absorb. Many of us quickly brush off positive feedback, which can be a big mistake, considering that it can improve our performance as much as or more than any other type of feedback.
- Follow up.
Follow up on the feedback you receive to demonstrate that you are committed to improving.
What following up sounds like
“Thank you for the feedback. I’ve been working on making my presentations more engaging. Could you let me know if you notice any improvements in my next presentation?”
- Express gratitude when you feel it.
Some say you should always express gratitude for the feedback you receive. I believe you should express gratitude if you genuinely feel grateful for it. There’s no need to perform. If the feedback feels harmful and way off base, consider using a feedback fallback phrase, which gives you some space to determine how to respond.
The Feedback Deck has a suit for each of the five feedback skills, seeking included. Every card distills one skill into something you can hold, share, and act on immediately.
If you manage people, make asking normal
Managers can play a major role in shaping what asking for feedback means on a team. Rather than a sign of weakness and uncertainty, asking can come to represent a confident desire to understand one’s strengths and weaknesses.
You do this by encouraging people to ask and by reducing the risks they associate with it. The best way I’ve found is to model the behavior you want. It’s one thing to tell your team that getting feedback is important, and quite another to demonstrate how it’s done.
Where there is psychological safety, it is far easier for everybody in the organization to engage in feedback-seeking behavior, because the team, the department, or even the entire organization treats it as a proactive act of growth. The final lesson covers building a feedback culture.
Take it further
Everything below is built on the five-component feedback literacy framework: seeking, receiving, processing, using, and giving. I made the deck so you could hold the work in your hands, the certifications so you could prove it, and the training so your whole organization can practice it.
The Feedback Deck
$2950 evidence-based cards across the five suits of feedback literacy. Every card distills one skill into something you can hold, share, and act on immediately, with a QR code linking to a companion video I recorded for that card.
Feedback Literacy Certification
$199 per tierThe Feedback Literacy Certification establishes your competency across all five skills. Completing it unlocks FLC-A, which extends the framework into organizational and leadership application. Both are self-paced and come with a LinkedIn credential.
Teams and enterprise
From $42 per employeeBring the deck and certifications to your whole organization, with a five-tier corporate rate card and enterprise deployment support.
Continue the course
All lessons in Constructive Feedback at Work
- Course Overview
- What is Constructive Feedback?
- Why is Feedback Important?
- Why is Feedback Challenging?
- How to Receive Feedback
- How to Process Feedback
- How to Use Feedback
- How to Give Feedback
- How to Ask for Feedback
- Building a Feedback Culture
Related: the feedback receiver’s mindset, frequently asked questions about one-on-one meetings, and the full feedback definition guide.
Read the full video transcript
Hi there and welcome to Module 5 where we will cover why asking for feedback is so important and how to go about doing it. Asking for feedback is perhaps the most effective way to get the feedback you need.
As we covered in Module 3 as it relates to using feedback, asking for feedback is an act of ownership – it’s you intentionally breaking what is in many places a business world norm of passively waiting for feedback – and going after it to get what you need.
We’ve mentioned Kobe Bryant throughout this course. Kobe had Phil Jackson as a coach, one of the greatest basketball coaches in history. Kobe certainly could have been a passive recipient of Coach Jackson’s feedback. Indeed, I’m sure many who have played for Coach Jackson did just that. But Kobe went to the next level. He received feedback from Coach Jackson, but as we covered, it didn’t end there. He also sought feedback from what he called GOAT Mountain, a group of six of the greatest living players.
In the academic literature on feedback, this type of behavior is referred to as “Feedback- Seeking-Behavior ,abbreviated as FSB. You can think of feedback-seeking behavior as referring to how individuals seek feedback either by reading the actions of others to infer what it means – in other words, to get feedback purely through observation, or by explicitly asking others for feedback.
This concept came to prominence thanks to this classic paper in 1983 by Susan Ashford and LL Cummings. This paper, to my understanding, was the first to really go deep in an exploration of what it means for feedback recipients in the workplace to play a major and proactive role, to truly be owners of their professional development.
This all leads to what they write here, that FSB is “proposed as an important component of the feedback process.” Earlier in the paper, the researchers first set the scene for why feedback is important. They write: “The positive effect of feedback on performance has been an accepted psychological principle since at least the early 1950s.”
Among the paper’s many insights on the importance of asking for feedback, and the paper does suggest that feedback receivers should ask for feedback more often, I want to bring our attention to a few particularly compelling passages. The authors state that these arguments “suggest that it may benefit both individual and organizations to not only give subordinates more feedback” and recall here some of the research we covered in the giving feedback module about how many managers completely avoid giving constructive feedback at all “as the current literature suggests, but also to improve the use of inquiry as a FSB strategy.”
In other words, to promote the use of asking for feedback as a strategic tool in the workplace. They go on to say that such a promotion can best be achieved by attempting to reduce some of the risk and effort costs involved in this strategy. In other words, the culture matters. If there’s psychological safety it will be far easier for everybody in the organization to engage in feedback seeking behavior because the team or department or even the entire organization will see it as a proactive act of growth.
Managers, they say, can play a major role in manipulating the shared meaning of this act. Rather than a sign of weakness and uncertainty, asking for feedback could come to represent a confident desire to understand one’s strengths and weaknesses.
Note how the authors specifically call out strengths here. We’ve covered it throughout this course, but I can’t reiterate it enough. Knowing your strengths is often just as and sometimes more important than understanding your weaknesses. A great ballet dancer, for example, could not have become great if they spent most of their time trying to shore up their weakness in geometry. Or, to get even more specific, they wouldn’t have been able to carve out their unique and differentiated strengths as a ballet dancer – perhaps their incredible ability to maintain posture and balance during dynamic pirouettes – if they spent most of their time trying to leap further.
If you’re interested in learning more about the importance of strengths, you might check out a book called Strengths-Based Leadership. I’ll link to it in the description.
The authors of our paper on FSB here conclude with “opening up this channel of feedback will allow employees to obtain more accurate appraisals of their work at the times when such appraisals are most valuable.” Lastly, let’s look at one other passage from this paper. “The perspective presented here is also beneficial in that it more accurately reflects how individuals actually acquire and respond to feedback in their organizational lives.
In situations where no verbal feedback is being given, our perspective argues that the individual is processing environmental cues and is deriving feedback information from them.” In other words, even in environments where nobody is providing feedback, feedback still remains.
They continue with “second, it is probably accurate to conceive of the individual as having several goals in his or her organizational life beyond present performance, and that each of these goals may serve as the organizing function of FSB.” In other words, as a feedback receiver you would do well to ask for feedback on a range of topics – from specific feedback directly tied to the task you are currently working on to perhaps more general feedback around how you may need to develop to move within your company from a director to a Vice President.
Even if we move out of the 1980s and into the modern era, we still find research highlighting the powerful role of asking for feedback. Consider this quote from a paper in 2022 titled Learning Leadership and Feedback Seeking Behavior: Leadership That Spurs Feedback Seeking. “Lifelong learning is crucial for professionals to continuously develop and update their knowledge and skills, and for organizations to create and sustain competitive advantage. In this regard, feedback-seeking is a powerful vehicle to gain new knowledge and insights in one’s development and performance.”
Okay, so let’s jump out of the research and into how to go about asking for feedback. First, come at this with a pure intention. What do I mean by that? Well, you may have experienced someone who seeks your feedback not necessarily to learn but to quickly get your approval so they can move forward with a project. That’s not really asking for feedback. Or, similarly, some seek feedback as a way to appease someone or to perform humility.
In other words, it’s more about the performance of being perceived as a humble feedback seeker than it is about gaining new knowledge and insights. So, to the extent possible, try to seek feedback genuinely and not with hidden motives.
Number two: ask your manager. This seems simple enough but it doesn’t happen as often as it should. And remember that you don’t need to wait until a quarterly performance review to do this, you might even start next week by saying to your manager “Hey. I’ve been watching a course on feedback and since we’ve been working together for insert time period, I’d like to get your feedback on how I’m doing, maybe what you see as my strengths and areas for growth.”
Number three, and this is especially true if you are a people manager, you should be regularly asking your team either via a survey, directly going individual by individual, or even going to the group after a project – if the latter you can pull everybody together after a project and ask how they think it went, what worked, and where you might have been able to do a better job as their leader. When this works, and it often does, you will both be receiving great feedback and also modeling for your team what feedback-seeking behavior looks like.
Number four is about indirect feedback seeking. Study those in your field or beyond who inspire you. Maybe you see those folks shining on LinkedIn or you saw them wow an audience at an industry conference or you’ve been reading their blog for years. Rather than merely be inspired, see them as a case study worth really digging into. What qualities do they bring to the table that you admire? What are their strengths? And is there anything about their strengths that you may be able to learn from to improve your own strengths or weaknesses?
Number five is about establishing peer-to-peer relationships, either within your organization or beyond. The research on peer-to-peer feedback is vast and it suggests that we can learn as much or more from meeting with a few peers than we can from meeting with with our manager. If you’re a digital marketer in a large organization, for example, you might reach out to another digital marketer at your same level who works on a completely different part of the business – perhaps you set up a monthly one-to-one conversation to share insights with each other.
You might also join an organization in your skill domain. This will connect you with a variety of peers who likely have a similar skill set but have learned to apply it across different sectors. Again, this could be a great opportunity to get feedback.
And, lastly, although there are plenty of other ways, ask for feedback after you interview somewhere. Although some on interview panels aren’t allowed to share their feedback, many are willing if you really push for it. This type of feedback can be especially helpful because this interviewer likely knows the type of talent they need and has perhaps already interviewed many other folks. Their feedback can help you see how you stack up in your field.
I’ve personally provided feedback to a few folks who I had great interviews with but who for various reasons didn’t fit what I was looking for. On several occasions, these folks sent me a response about how my feedback meant the world to them and will help both with their development and in their future interviews.
Okay team, that concludes Module 5: Asking for Feedback. I’ll see you over at our final module.