Cameron ConawayFeedback Literacy for All

The Feedback Guide

One-on-One Meetings: A Guide for Managers and Employees, with 100 Questions

A one-on-one meeting is a regular, private conversation between a manager and one direct report, held for the direct report’s benefit: their priorities, their obstacles, their growth, and feedback in both directions. This guide covers both seats at the table: how often to meet, how to run the meeting, 100 questions to ask, five agendas to borrow, and how to exchange feedback once you are in the room.

By Professor Cameron Conaway, Penn State Smeal College of Business

Start where you are

A one-on-one has two seats, and each one comes with different work. Pick the row that matches yours.

If you areStart with
Managing people
Starting one-on-ones with your teamHow to run a one-on-oneSeven steps, from the calendar invite to the follow-up.
Short of an agenda for tomorrowFive one-on-one agendasTimed outlines for five kinds of meeting.
Out of things to askQuestions for managers to ask60 questions in ten groups.
Postponing a piece of feedbackHow to exchange feedbackWhy the one-on-one is the place for it, with wording.
Managing a remote teamRemote and hybrid one-on-onesWhat changes when you are not in the same building.
Meeting with your manager
Stuck in meetings that feel like status updatesHow to get more from your own one-on-oneFive things to bring, and what to say when the meeting drifts.
Unsure what to ask your managerQuestions to ask your manager40 questions in eight groups.
Dealing with a manager who keeps cancelingIf your manager cancelsA message to send, and a way to ask for the meeting back.
Wanting feedback you never getHow to ask for feedbackThe question that works better than “any feedback for me?”
Running the system
Choosing a cadenceHow often and how longThe research, and a cadence for five situations.
Making the case for one-on-onesWhy one-on-ones matterFive findings, with sources.
Meeting with your managers’ direct reportsSkip-level one-on-onesWhat they are for, and how to keep them fair to the manager in between.
Connecting one-on-ones to reviewsOne-on-ones and performance reviewsHow one feeds the other.

What is a one-on-one meeting?

A one-on-one meeting is a recurring, private conversation between a manager and one direct report. It is also written 1:1 or 1-on-1, and called a one-to-one in British English. Most last about 30 minutes and happen every week or two. The topics come mostly from the direct report: what they are working on, what is in their way, how they are doing, and where they want to go.

Whose meeting is it?

The direct report’s. In a 2022 Harvard Business Review article, organizational psychologist Steven Rogelberg drew on surveys and on interviews with leaders at Fortune 100 companies. His first guideline is that the manager should treat the meeting as time set aside for the direct report, and say so.

What a one-on-one is not

MeetingWhat it is forWho sets the topicsHow often
One-on-oneThe direct report’s priorities, obstacles, growth, and feedback in both directionsMostly the direct reportEvery week or two
Status updateReporting progress on tasksThe manager or the project planAs the project requires
Performance reviewA formal summary of a period, often tied to payThe organization’s processOne to four times a year

What a one-on-one is for

  • Alignment. Making sure this week’s work matches the team’s priorities.
  • Obstacles. Finding what is slowing the person down while it is still small.
  • Feedback. Exchanging it in both directions, in small amounts, close to the event.
  • Growth. Talking about skills, career, and the working relationship itself.

Why one-on-ones matter

Because a regular, private conversation is where a manager’s attention, support, and feedback reach one person at a time. They are also common. One-on-ones make up nearly half of all workplace meetings, according to a 2023 paper in Organizational Psychology Review. Five findings make the case for doing them well.

  1. Weekly meaningful conversations go with high engagement.

    Gallup reports that 80% of employees who received meaningful feedback in the past week were fully engaged. In the same article, only 16% of nearly 15,000 employees called their last conversation with their manager extremely meaningful.

  2. Meeting more often makes the meetings easier.

    In a Humu survey of 350 managers and individual contributors, reported in MIT Sloan Management Review, weekly one-on-ones went with less anxiety about the meetings (20% lower), less dread (17% lower), and a stronger sense of success at work (12% higher) among individual contributors, compared with less frequent meetings.

  3. The direct report should do most of the talking.

    In Glad We Met: The Art and Science of 1:1 Meetings, Rogelberg reports that the best predictor of a one-on-one’s value is how actively the direct report takes part, and that the balance works best when the direct report does between 50% and 90% of the talking. Managers and direct reports both rated meetings highest when the direct report had a hand in the agenda.

  4. How the meeting is run matters more than how often it happens.

    In a 2022 doctoral study at the University of North Carolina at Charlotte, supervised by Rogelberg, 303 employees answered two surveys about their one-on-ones. The quality of the meetings did more for engagement than their frequency, and what mattered most was how well the manager attended to the person and the relationship.

  5. Going without them has a cost.

    The same MIT Sloan Management Review article reports that one in four people have no regular one-on-one with a manager or a direct report, and that people without one-on-ones are more likely to leave their organizations.

What the findings add up to

Three things do most of the work: meeting regularly, letting the direct report lead, and following through. If you have to choose, protect the quality of the meeting before its frequency. The rest of this guide is built on those three.

How often and how long

Meet every week for about 30 minutes. If that is not possible, meet every two weeks for 45 to 60 minutes, and protect the time. Rogelberg’s research found a weekly half hour to be the best cadence, and a longer meeting every other week to be the second best. Gallup’s research points the same way: 15 to 30 minutes is enough when the conversation happens every week, and frequent short conversations do more than occasional long ones. Cadence is not everything, though. In the study of 303 employees described above, how well the meetings were run mattered more than how often they happened.

SituationCadenceWhy
New hire, or new in a roleWeekly, and more often in the first monthQuestions pile up fast in the first 90 days
Remote or hybridWeeklyIt replaces the hallway conversations that no longer happen
Experienced and steadyWeekly or every two weeksAsk which they prefer, and revisit the answer twice a year
Hourly or shift-based10 to 15 minutes, every week or twoShort and regular does more than long and rare
A team of ten or moreEvery two weeks, for 30 minutesA cadence you keep is better than one you cancel

If you have to cancel

Move the meeting. Don’t cancel it. A canceled one-on-one tells the person that their time is the first thing to go, and Rogelberg advises rescheduling right away when a conflict can’t be avoided.

Too often, or not often enough?

The signs of too often are thin agendas and meetings that end early every week. The signs of not often enough are long lists, surprises, and problems you hear about late. Adjust, and ask the person which they would choose.

How to run a one-on-one

Put it on the calendar, let the direct report set most of the agenda, listen more than you talk, and end with next steps in writing. Seven steps cover it.

  1. Make it recurring.

    Book the same time every week, and treat it as fixed. A one-on-one that happens “when there is time” stops happening.

  2. Share one running document.

    Both of you add topics before the meeting. Notes and action items go in the same place, so that each meeting starts where the last one ended.

  3. Let the direct report set most of the agenda.

    Ask them to add their topics a day ahead, and put yours underneath. If their list is always empty, the questions in this guide are a place to start.

  4. Open with the person, not the project.

    One question is enough: “What’s on your mind this week?” Then follow the answer before you turn to your own list.

  5. Listen more than you talk.

    Aim for the direct report to do well over half of the talking. Ask a second question before you offer a solution, and when their solution would work, use theirs.

  6. Exchange feedback every time.

    A little, in both directions. The section on feedback in one-on-ones has the wording.

  7. End with next steps, and write them down.

    Say who will do what by when, put it in the shared document, and open the next meeting there.

Five one-on-one meeting agendas

An agenda for a one-on-one is a short list of topics with rough times, and most of the topics come from the direct report. It keeps the meeting from sliding into a status update. Borrow one of these five, and adjust the minutes to fit.

The weekly 30-minute one-on-one

For most managers and direct reports, most weeks.

5 minutes

Check in. “What’s on your mind this week?” Follow the answer before anything else.

12 minutes

Their topics. Work through the direct report’s list, in their order.

5 minutes

Your topics. Context they need, decisions you have made, and anything you owe them.

5 minutes

Feedback, both ways. One thing each: something that worked, or something to adjust.

3 minutes

Next steps. Who will do what by when, written in the shared document.

The first one-on-one with a new direct report

For a new hire, or when you inherit a team. Plan on 45 minutes. The goal is to learn how the person works before you discuss any of the work.

5 minutes

The purpose. Say what the meeting is for: “This time is yours. I’ll bring a few things, and your topics come first.”

15 minutes

Their story. What they have done before, what they want from this role, and what the best manager they ever had did for them.

10 minutes

How they work. How they like to receive feedback, how they like to be recognized, and what tends to frustrate them.

10 minutes

How you work. What you expect, how you make decisions, and how to reach you when something is urgent.

5 minutes

The rhythm. Agree on the day, the length, and the shared document.

The 15-minute check-in for hourly and shift-based teams

For retail, hospitality, health care, warehouse, and other shift work. Hold it at the start or end of a shift, away from the floor.

3 minutes

The week. “What went well this week, and what got in your way?”

5 minutes

Anything in the way. Scheduling, equipment, training, or a situation with a customer or a coworker.

4 minutes

Feedback. One specific thing they did well, and one thing to adjust if there is one.

3 minutes

What is ahead. Upcoming shifts, changes on the way, and one thing they would like to learn.

The monthly growth conversation

Once a month or once a quarter, set the week’s work aside and talk about the longer arc. Plan on 45 minutes.

10 minutes

Recent work. What they are proud of, and what they learned from it.

15 minutes

Direction. Where they want to be in a year or two, and which skills that will take.

15 minutes

The next stretch. One project, one skill, or one introduction that would move them toward it.

5 minutes

Commitments. One step for each of you before the next growth conversation.

The one-on-one about a concern

For a missed deadline, a pattern, or friction with a colleague. Plan on 30 minutes, and name the topic in advance so that it is not a surprise.

3 minutes

The topic. “I’d like to use today to talk about the last two client deadlines.”

7 minutes

Their account first. “Tell me what happened from your side.” Listen before you describe your concern.

8 minutes

What you observed, and its effect. Specific events in plain language, and why they matter.

9 minutes

A plan, built together. What will change, what support they need, and what you will do.

3 minutes

The follow-up. A date to check in, written down.

For the wording of the concern itself, borrow from these 40 examples of constructive feedback, or choose a structure from the guide to feedback models.

A one-on-one meeting template

Copy these five headings into a document that both of you can edit. Add a dated entry for each meeting, with the newest on top.

  1. Carried over

    Next steps from last time, and whether each one is done.

  2. Their topics

    Added by the direct report, a day ahead.

  3. Manager’s topics

    Added underneath, and kept short.

  4. Feedback

    One thing each, in a sentence.

  5. Next steps

    Who will do what by when.

One-on-one questions for managers to ask

The best one-on-one questions are open, specific, and followed by silence. Choose one or two for each meeting. Ask ten in a row and the conversation becomes an interview.

These 60 questions are grouped by purpose. The numbers run through the whole guide, up to 100, so that you can note the ones that work for you.

Opening questions

To start with the person before the project. Ask one, and follow the answer.

  1. What’s on your mind this week?
  2. How are you, and how is the week treating you?
  3. What was the best part of your week?
  4. What is taking more energy than it should?
  5. What would make this half hour most useful for you?
  6. Is there anything from last time that we should pick back up?

Questions about priorities

To check that this week’s work matches what matters most.

  1. What are your top three priorities right now?
  2. Is any priority unclear, or competing with another one?
  3. What are you working on that I might not know about?
  4. If you had to drop one thing this week, what would it be?
  5. What decision are you waiting on, and from whom?
  6. How would you describe a good week right now?

Questions about obstacles

To find what is in the way while it is still small.

  1. What is slowing you down?
  2. Where are you stuck, and what have you tried?
  3. What do you need from me this week?
  4. Is there a tool, a contact, or a decision that would unblock you?
  5. Which meetings or tasks could we take off your plate?
  6. What problem keeps coming back?

Questions that open feedback for them

To begin a feedback conversation by asking before telling.

  1. How do you think that project went?
  2. What would you do differently next time?
  3. Can I share something I noticed in Tuesday’s meeting?
  4. What kind of feedback is most useful to you right now?
  5. How do you prefer to receive feedback: in the moment, or in our one-on-one?
  6. What have you heard from others about your work lately?

Questions that invite feedback for you

To make it safe to say what is hard to say to a manager. Ask one, then listen without defending.

  1. What is one thing I could do differently to make your work easier?
  2. What should I start, stop, or keep doing as your manager?
  3. When did I last make your job harder?
  4. Am I giving you too much direction, too little, or about the right amount?
  5. Is there a decision of mine that you disagreed with and didn’t mention?
  6. What do you wish I asked you about more often?

Questions about growth and career

For the monthly growth conversation, or whenever the week allows.

  1. What part of your job do you want more of?
  2. What skill do you want to build this quarter?
  3. Where do you want to be in two years?
  4. What project would stretch you in a good way?
  5. Who in the company would you like to learn from?
  6. What is one thing you’ve learned recently?

Questions about workload and well-being

To catch strain early. Ask, and leave room for a short answer.

  1. How is your workload, on a scale of one to ten?
  2. What are you working on outside your normal hours?
  3. When did you last take real time off?
  4. What is the most draining part of your week?
  5. Is there anything going on that would help me to know about? Share only what you want to.
  6. What would make this month more sustainable?

Questions about the team

To learn what you would not hear in a group meeting.

  1. How is the team working together right now?
  2. Who deserves recognition that I might have missed?
  3. Where is collaboration with another team breaking down?
  4. Is there tension on the team that I should know about?
  5. Whose input do you wish you had more often?
  6. What should the team stop doing?

Questions for new hires

For the first 90 days, when a new person’s questions are most useful to you.

  1. What has surprised you so far?
  2. What is still unclear about your role?
  3. Who have you met, and who should you meet next?
  4. What do we do here that seems strange to someone new?
  5. What do you need in order to feel fully set up?
  6. How does the job compare with what you expected when you accepted it?

Questions for skip-level meetings

For a conversation with someone who reports to one of your managers.

  1. What is going well on your team that I should protect?
  2. What gets in the way of your best work?
  3. What do you wish leadership understood about your job?
  4. How clear are the team’s priorities from where you sit?
  5. What would you change if you were in my seat?
  6. What is one thing your manager does that helps you?

How to ask them well

  • Ask one at a time. A stacked question gets an answer to its easiest part.
  • Wait. Count to five before you speak again. The second answer is usually the useful one.
  • Follow up once. “Tell me more about that” does more than a new question.
  • Do something with the answer. A question that leads nowhere teaches people to give short answers.

One-on-one questions to ask your manager

Your one-on-one is the one meeting where your questions set the agenda. Bring two or three. The most useful ones are specific enough for your manager to answer in a few sentences, and the answer changes what you do next.

Questions about expectations

To confirm what matters most before you spend the week on it.

  1. What is the most important thing for me to get right this month?
  2. If I can only finish one of these, which should it be?
  3. How will you know that this project succeeded?
  4. Has anything changed in the team’s priorities that affects my work?
  5. What should I say no to?

Questions that get you feedback

Name the piece of work, and ask for one thing. Narrow questions get answers you can use.

  1. What is one thing I did well this week, and one thing I could do better?
  2. How did my presentation land with the leadership team?
  3. What should I do more of?
  4. Where am I falling short of what you need?
  5. What have you heard about my work from other teams?

Questions about growth and career

For a growth conversation, once a month or once a quarter.

  1. What skill would make the biggest difference to my work?
  2. What would I need to demonstrate to move to the next level?
  3. Which upcoming project could stretch me?
  4. Who should I be learning from?
  5. How do you think about my path over the next year or two?

Questions that get you unblocked

Bring the problem and what you have tried. Then ask for one thing: a decision, an introduction, or advice.

  1. I’m stuck on the vendor contract. Can we think it through together?
  2. Can you make this decision today, or tell me who can?
  3. Could you introduce me to the right person on the finance team?
  4. Which of these two options would you choose, and why?
  5. What would you do in my position?

Questions about context

To learn what your manager knows that you don’t.

  1. What is leadership most concerned about right now?
  2. How does my work connect to this year’s goals?
  3. What is coming in the next quarter that I should prepare for?
  4. Why did we decide to go that way?
  5. What are you working on that I could help with?

Questions about working together

Best asked early with a new manager, and again once a year.

  1. How do you prefer to get updates from me?
  2. What is the best way to bring you bad news?
  3. When should I decide on my own, and when should I check with you?
  4. Is there anything I do that makes your job harder?
  5. What could we change about these meetings to make them more useful?

Openers for challenging topics

Say the topic in one sentence, and then ask for the conversation.

  1. My workload is more than I can do well. Can we decide what moves?
  2. I’m having trouble working with a colleague. Can I talk it through with you?
  3. I disagreed with a decision last week. Can I explain why?
  4. I made a mistake on the report. Can I tell you what happened and what I’ve done about it?
  5. I’d like more feedback than I’m getting. Could we make it a standing item?

Questions for a new manager

For your first one-on-one with a manager who is new to you.

  1. What do you expect from me in the first month?
  2. How do you like to run one-on-ones?
  3. What should I know about how you make decisions?
  4. What has worked well with people you’ve managed before?
  5. What do you want to know about how I work?

Add your questions to the shared document a day ahead. Most managers give a better answer with a day to think.

How to exchange feedback in a one-on-one

Make feedback a standing item, keep each piece small, and let it run in both directions. The one-on-one is the best place for most feedback. It is private, it comes around every week, and it is close to the events you are discussing.

  • Private. Feedback about what to change is easier to hear without an audience.
  • Regular. When feedback comes up every week, each piece is small and none of it is a surprise.
  • Close to the event. The details are fresh, and there is still time to do something with them.

If you are the manager

  1. Ask before you tell.

    “How do you think the client call went?” People often name the issue themselves, and the conversation is easier when they do.

  2. Describe one event and its effect.

    Say what happened in plain words, and what it led to. The SBI model gives the structure: situation, behavior, impact.

  3. Ask for their side.

    “What was happening for you?” You may learn something that changes the feedback.

  4. Agree on one next step.

    One change, and a date to come back to it.

  5. Ask for feedback in return.

    “What is one thing I could do differently to make your work easier?” Then thank them, and act on something they said.

What a manager might say

Recognition

“In Tuesday’s review, you asked the newest person on the team for her opinion first. She told me afterward that it was the first time she had spoken in that meeting. Keep doing that.”

An adjustment

“The report reached the client a day after we promised it, and they had to move their own review. What got in the way, and what would help next time?”

A pattern

“This is the third standup this month that you joined late. The team waits to start, and it costs everyone ten minutes. What is going on, and what would make the start time work?”

For more wording, the guide to constructive feedback has 40 examples by situation.

How to ask for feedback

“Any feedback for me?” almost always gets the same answer: “No, you’re doing fine.” The question is too wide to answer on the spot. Narrow it in three ways.

  • Name the work. “The client presentation on Tuesday.”
  • Ask for one thing. “One thing I could have done better.”
  • Point it forward. “Before the next one.”

Together: “What is one thing I could do better in the next client presentation?” Then listen, say thank you, and resist the urge to explain. If you want more, ask for an example. The lesson on how to ask for feedback goes further.

When the feedback is for your manager

Wait to be asked, or ask first: “Can I offer a thought on how the planning meeting went?” Describe the effect on your work, and suggest one change: “When priorities change on Thursday, I lose a day of work. Could we settle the week on Monday?” The guide to performance reviews has eight more examples of feedback for a manager.

Five skills in half an hour

A good one-on-one uses all five skills of feedback literacy in Cameron Conaway’s framework: seeking feedback, receiving it, processing it, using it, and giving it. Few meetings give you the chance to practice all five every week.

How to get more from your own one-on-one

Treat it as your meeting: bring the agenda, ask for what you need, and leave with next steps. The research points one way. The more actively you take part, the more the meeting is worth to both of you.

Five things to bring

  1. A win.

    One thing that went well, in a sentence. Your manager can’t recognize work they haven’t heard about.

  2. Your priorities.

    The two or three things you plan to spend the week on, so that your manager can confirm them or redirect you.

  3. An obstacle.

    What is in your way, and what you have already tried.

  4. A request.

    A decision, an introduction, a resource, or advice. Say exactly what would help.

  5. One feedback question.

    Keep it narrow, and tie it to a piece of work. The section on how to ask for feedback has the wording.

If the meeting turns into a status update

Send the status ahead of time. A short written update the day before clears the meeting for everything else. Then open with: “I sent my update yesterday. Could we use today for two things I’d like your thinking on?”

If your manager cancels

Ask for the time back the same day: “I noticed we missed our one-on-one this week. Could we reschedule? I’d like to review priorities and ask for your feedback.”

If cancellations become a pattern, name the pattern once, without blame: “Our one-on-ones have moved three times this month, and they help me stay on track. Is there a time that would be easier to protect?” Offering a shorter meeting often helps. Twenty minutes that happen are worth more than 45 that don’t.

If you don’t have one-on-ones

Ask for one: “I’d value some dedicated time to discuss priorities and feedback. Could we set up a one-on-one?” Suggest a trial of 30 minutes every two weeks for two months, and offer to bring the agenda. A small, specific request is easy to say yes to.

Remote and hybrid one-on-ones

Meet every week, spend the first minutes on the person, and write more down. A remote one-on-one has to replace the hallway conversations that no longer happen, so it carries more than a meeting between two people in the same building does.

  • Protect the cadence. For someone who works remotely, the one-on-one may be the only regular contact with you. It is also the easiest meeting to cancel.
  • Start with the person. Without a hallway, the first five minutes are where you learn how someone is doing.
  • Close everything else. Turn off notifications and close the other windows. On a call, divided attention is easy to detect.
  • Write more down. The shared document matters more when you can’t stop by a desk. Put decisions and next steps in it before the call ends.
  • Share the awkward hours. Across time zones, rotate the early and late slots, so that the same person is not always meeting at 7 a.m.
  • Change the format now and then. A phone call while both of you walk can open a conversation that a screen keeps formal.
  • Ask about connection. “Who have you worked with this week, apart from me?” A short answer is worth following up.

Mistakes that are specific to remote one-on-ones

They are the reverse of that list: multitasking during the call, going straight to tasks, canceling when the calendar fills, and sending by chat the feedback that deserves a conversation.

Skip-level one-on-ones

A skip-level one-on-one is a meeting between a leader and someone who reports to one of that leader’s managers. Its purpose is to listen. The leader learns how the work feels two levels down, and the employee gets time with the person who sets direction. Every six to twelve months per person is enough for most teams.

How to keep it fair to the manager in between

  • Tell the manager first. Explain that skip-levels are routine and are not a response to a problem.
  • Tell the employee the purpose. “This is not an evaluation of you or of your manager. I’m here to learn.”
  • Ask about the work. Ask what helps and what gets in the way. Don’t ask for a rating of the manager. The skip-level questions are written this way.
  • Leave the manager’s decisions with the manager. When an issue belongs to them, take it back to them. Don’t settle it in the room.
  • Share themes, not quotes. Say at the start what you will pass on, and protect who said what.
  • Close the loop. Tell people what you heard across the conversations, and what will change because of it.

If you are invited to one

Bring one thing that is going well, one obstacle that is bigger than your team, and one question about where the organization is headed. Describe situations and their effects, and leave out verdicts on people. That is honest, and it is fair to your manager.

Notes, follow-up, and tracking

Keep one shared document, write down decisions and next steps before the meeting ends, and open the next meeting by reading them. Notes are what turn a good conversation into something that changes the week.

What to write down

  • Decisions. One line each.
  • Next steps. Each with a name and a date.
  • Feedback exchanged. A sentence for each piece, so that it can be found at review time.
  • Topics carried over. Anything you ran out of time for.

Ask before you write down anything personal. Some things are said to be heard, not recorded.

Who takes the notes?

Both of you. The person who makes a commitment writes it down. The direct report owns their next steps, and the manager owns theirs.

After the meeting

Within a day, do the first thing you promised. Follow-through is what tells the other person that the meeting matters, and it is easy to skip.

How to know whether your one-on-ones are working

  • They happen. Compare the meetings held with the meetings scheduled.
  • They have an agenda. Most of it comes from the direct report.
  • Next steps get done. Check the list at the start of every meeting.
  • People say they are useful. Twice a year, ask: “What should we change about these meetings?”
  • Engagement moves. If your organization runs engagement surveys, compare the answers about manager support with how regularly one-on-ones happen.

Mistakes to avoid

Each of these eight is common, and each has a simple fix.

MistakeWhat it costsWhat to do instead
Turning it into a status updateThe direct report’s topics never come upGet status in writing beforehand, and spend the meeting on what needs a conversation
Canceling when the week fillsThe person learns that their time is the first thing to goMove it within the same week, or hold a shorter one
Doing most of the talkingYou learn nothing new, and they stop bringing topicsAsk a question, and wait. Aim to talk for well under half the time
Arriving without an agendaThe meeting drifts to whatever is urgentShare one document, and add topics a day ahead
Ending without next stepsThe same topics come back next weekWrite who will do what by when before you leave
Keeping it all work, or all chatYou miss either the person or the progressStart with the person, and then move to their topics
Saving feedback for the reviewSmall issues grow, and the review brings surprisesExchange one piece of feedback in every meeting
Splitting your attentionThe person stops raising what mattersSilence notifications, and close the laptop or the other windows

Mistakes direct reports make

  • Arriving with nothing. An empty agenda hands the meeting back to your manager.
  • Waiting to be asked. If something matters to you, put it on the list.
  • Bringing only good news, or only problems. Your manager needs both to help you.
  • Letting your own next steps slide. Follow-through runs in both directions.

One-on-ones and performance reviews

One-on-ones are where the work of a performance review gets done ahead of time. A review summarizes a period. Regular one-on-ones are how both people know what the summary will say before anyone writes it.

  • No surprises. When feedback is exchanged in small amounts every week, nothing in the review should be new.
  • A record of the whole period. A year of notes gives both people specific examples from every month. That counters the pull toward judging the year by its last few weeks.
  • A place for the goals to live. Goals set in a review fade unless someone returns to them. Put one development goal on the one-on-one agenda each month.

Keep the two meetings distinct. A one-on-one that becomes a weekly evaluation stops being the direct report’s meeting. The guide to performance reviews covers both seats, with 100 examples and 22 questions to ask.

Questions and answers

What is a one-on-one meeting?

A one-on-one meeting is a regular, private conversation between a manager and one direct report, held for the direct report’s benefit. It usually lasts about 30 minutes and happens every week or two. It covers priorities, obstacles, growth, and feedback in both directions. It is also written 1:1 or 1-on-1.

What is the purpose of a one-on-one meeting?

The purpose is to give one person a manager’s full attention on a regular schedule. The meeting keeps work matched to priorities, brings obstacles up early, makes room for feedback in both directions, and builds the working relationship. It exists for the direct report’s success, which is why they set most of the agenda.

How often should one-on-one meetings happen?

Weekly is best for most managers and direct reports. Organizational psychologist Steven Rogelberg’s research found a 30-minute meeting every week to be the best cadence, and a 45- to 60-minute meeting every two weeks to be the second best. A monthly meeting leaves a long gap in which small problems can grow.

How long should a one-on-one be?

About 30 minutes when you meet every week, and 45 to 60 minutes when you meet every two weeks. Hourly and shift-based teams often do well with 10 to 15 minutes. Gallup’s research suggests that 15 to 30 minutes is enough when the conversation happens weekly.

Who should set the agenda for a one-on-one?

The direct report sets most of it, and the manager adds a few topics. Both add items to a shared document a day before the meeting. In Rogelberg’s research, managers and direct reports both rated one-on-ones highest when the direct report had helped create the agenda.

What should I talk about in a one-on-one with my manager?

Bring five things: a recent win, your priorities for the week, one obstacle, one request, and one question that asks for feedback on a specific piece of work. Send routine status updates in writing beforehand, so that the meeting can go to what needs a conversation.

What questions should a manager ask in a one-on-one?

Start with an open question, such as “What’s on your mind this week?” Then ask about priorities, about obstacles, and about what the person needs from you. Ask for feedback on your own work as a manager, too. This guide lists 60 questions for managers in ten groups.

How do you give feedback in a one-on-one?

Make feedback a standing item on the agenda. Ask for the person’s own account first, describe one specific event and its effect, ask for their side, and agree on one next step. Then ask for feedback on your own work. A small amount every week is easier to hear and to use than a large amount once a quarter.

What is the difference between a one-on-one and a performance review?

A one-on-one is frequent, informal, and led mostly by the direct report. A performance review is a formal summary of a period, run on the organization’s schedule and often tied to pay. Regular one-on-ones make reviews easier, because most of the feedback has already been exchanged.

Should you take notes in a one-on-one?

Yes. Keep one shared document with the agenda, the decisions, and the next steps, and give each next step a name and a date. Ask before you record anything personal. The notes make follow-up easier, and they give both people specific examples when review time comes.

What is a skip-level one-on-one?

A skip-level one-on-one is a meeting between a leader and an employee who reports to one of that leader’s managers. It gives the leader a direct account of how the work is going, and it gives the employee time with senior leadership. Every six to twelve months per person is enough for most teams.

What should I do if my manager keeps canceling our one-on-ones?

Ask to reschedule right away, and say why the meeting matters to you. If it keeps happening, name the pattern once and offer an easier format, such as 20 minutes every two weeks. Arriving with a short agenda each time gives your manager a reason to protect the meeting.

Do one-on-ones work for hourly or shift-based employees?

Yes. Keep them short and regular: 10 to 15 minutes every week or two, held at the start or end of a shift and away from the floor. Cover how the week went, anything in the way, one piece of specific feedback, and what is coming next.

Practice before your next one-on-one

A one-on-one calls on all five feedback skills in half an hour. They are easier to build before the meeting than during it.

The five-minute feedback practice

Free

Fifteen real situations. One page of feedback that is yours to keep and share.

Start the practice

The Feedback Deck

$29

50 evidence-based cards across the five skills of feedback literacy, each with a three-minute companion video. Bring one card to your next one-on-one.

Explore the deck

Feedback Literacy Certification

$199

Establishes your competency across all five feedback literacy skills. Self-paced, with an exam and a LinkedIn credential upon completion.

Explore the certification

Feedback training for teams

By quote

Keynotes, workshops, and audits with Professor Cameron Conaway.

Explore feedback training